Traitors Fans Share “Wildcard” Season 5 Cast Predictions
PEACOCK / STUDIO LAMBERT / THE TRAITORS
As The Traitors US Season 4 concluded on Peacock with Rob Rausch's dramatic win, fans immediately shifted focus to Season 5.
With casting reportedly in its final stages and rumors swirling about a potential all-star follow-up in Season 6, fans on Reddit, X (formerly Twitter), Instagram, and TikTok are buzzing with fantasy casts.
Take a peek at some of The Traitors Season 5 cast predictions below.
PEACOCK / STUDIO LAMBERT / THE TRAITORS
On Reddit's r/TheTraitorsUS, multiple "Dream Cast for Season 5" threads highlight recurring picks.
Users push for Rob Cesternino and Tyson Apostol from Survivor for strategic depth, Devin Walker from The Challenge for some unpredictable drama, and Housewives like Monique Samuels, NeNe Leakes, Kenya Moore, and Kyle Richards.
The Traitors Wildcards
Other favorites include Bianca Del Rio (RuPaul's Drag Race), Scott Disick, and wildcards like Ronald from Jury Duty or Snooki.
PEACOCK / STUDIO LAMBERT / THE TRAITORS
A viral BuzzFeed article from early February 2026 amplified the hype, listing 15 must-have names for Season 5.
Whitney Leavitt (The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives), comedian Brittany Broski, Scott Disick, Paige DeSorbo (Summer House), Bowen Yang (SNL), Jason Kelce (NFL), and Amelia Dimoldenberg were among them.
X Users Have Plenty Of ideas
On X, discussions lean toward Bravo stars and athletes, with posts suggesting the likes of Da'Vonne Rogers (Big Brother) or Honey Boo Boo.
Over on Instagram and TikTok, drag queens Olympians, Natasha Lyonne, and Ziwe have also been put forward.
PEACOCK / STUDIO LAMBERT / THE TRAITORS
Overall, it seems the Traitors fandom demands diversity — clueless celebs for early murders, stone-cold gamers for late-game twists, and messy influencers for round-table fireworks.
Peacock is keeping cast details tightly under wraps (with a non-celebrity spinoff also in production for NBC), but one thing’s for sure: Season 5 can't arrive soon enough!
